FAILDEX失樂園
中文

Manilla

The business, the turning points, and the decisions behind them.

Event year2014

01 / WHAT IT BUILT

What the company did

Manilla was a free personal account management service incubated within and backed by Hearst Corporation, launched in beta in February 2011. It gave consumers one secure access point to all household accounts - bills, finances, travel rewards programs and magazine subscriptions - under a single password, with bill-pay reminders and lifetime document storage. By July 2013 it had 500,000 activated users. The company shut down on July 1, 2014.

02 / Manilla FAILURE REASONS

Failure reasons

Manilla's official shutdown explanation was blunt: the company was unable to achieve the scale necessary to make the economics of the business viable. The free service never found a revenue model or mass adoption sufficient to sustain it - it had announced 500,000 users a year earlier against ambitions of over a million, while rival Check was being acquired by Intuit. It ceased operations on July 1, 2014, within days of releasing a major app update.

03 / EVENT HISTORY

Events in the structured record

  1. Operations ended

    Manilla ended operations.

04 / CONTEMPORARY REBUILD ASSESSMENT

Difficulty of rebuilding this project today

Material for this section is being gathered and checked. It will appear here once ready.

Rebuild difficultyPending assessmentNot completed
Scoring basisNot completed
ScalabilityPending assessmentNot completed
Scoring basisNot completed

Overall assessment: Not completed

05 / CAUSAL CHAIN

How the factors connect

  1. 01

    Launched in beta February 2011 by Hearst Corporation as a free personal account management service; launch partners included Comcast and Citibank.

  2. 02

    Named one of Time Inc.'s '10 NYC Startups to Watch in 2011'; won a 2012 Webby Award.

  3. 03

    Topped 500,000 activated users in July 2013 (doubling in six months); users linked 3 million accounts from 3,500 businesses.

  4. 04

    Announced shutdown in May 2014; ceased operations July 1, 2014, citing inability to reach the scale needed for viable economics.

  5. 05

    No reliable loss figure disclosed.